Chasing the Headless Horseman: The History, Hijinks, and Halloweens of the Real Sleepy Hollow by J. W. Ocker
Skyrocketing food and grocery prices. Pain at the pump.
Another seemingly endless war while the president thrives on AI generated
praise and glory. While doom and gloom seem to abound in 2026, I’ll remember it
as the year that readers received two J. W. Ocker travel books. Ocker, who has clearly
established the field of horror travel writing, researching and visiting the
haunted, mysterious, and dangerous places that are often populated by cryptids,
ghosts, or legends, published the wonderfully weird Don’t Go There over
the summer, which I found was an ideal book to find out about places not to
visit (even though there’s some on my to visit list like The Pine Barrens and
Centralia). Just in time for the Halloween season, Ocker’s latest book covers
everything you never knew you wanted to know about Sleepy Hallow, which Ocker
makes the case was the setting for America’s first horror story, written by
America’s first professional writer, Washington Irving. Beyond being a travel
book that provides the history and current status of one of the US’s hottest
Halloween towns, Ocker makes the case for the importance of the Headless
Horseman to American horror and how this story possibly affected literature in
America and around the world. I was amazed to learn about the possible
influences on Poe and Dickens, as well Irving’s contributions to the English
lexicon with words like knickerbocker, doughnut, the almighty dollar, and
Gotham. Ocker uses these facts to make a strong case about Irving’s importance
not just to American literature but to American culture and norms. Chasing the Headless Horseman is not just a travelogue about exploring the
transformation of North Tarrytown to Sleep Hollow, but rather it’s also a love
letter and passionate endorsement of the significance of the Headless Horseman
to America’s monsterverse and how it has factored in to our urban legends and lore.
I am so thankful that W.W. Norton & Company and NetGalley made this book
available for preview.
Chasing the Headless Horseman is a great book because
it not only examines how the Halloween and fall seasons transform Sleepy Hollow
into a in-demand destination filled with graveyard visits, instagramable shots
on bridges, and cursed rock formations, but Ocker also presents the history of
the town, tracing it from its earliest days as Weckquaesgeek land to eventually
becoming a Dutch settlement where Frederick Philipse established a mansion and
mill. Ocker also dedicates chapters to examining Sunnyside, Washington Irving’s
still preserved home in the area, providing some details about how the unique
construction came to be. However, Ocker also interviews many current and former
residents of Sleepy Hollow and neighboring Tarrytown to share more about the
history and significance of the area, and to better understand what it is like
living in the area. These interviews are some of the best parts of the book as
they provide first hand perspectives of citizens who have contributed to Sleepy
Hollow’s transformation over the years. They also showcase a sillier side of
Ocker, and I found myself laughing at some of the questions and responses in
these interviews. It was also fascinating to learn that the Sleepy Hollow/Tarrytown
high school’s mascot is the Headless Horseman, which Ocker shares his fascination
with by opening the book describing a bathroom redecoration project featuring the
Headless Horseman.
In addition to the history of the area, Ocker also explores
his love of the story and how a middle school teacher’s lesson for Halloween
introduced him to the story that would become a lifelong love. This passion for
“The Legend of Sleepy Hollow” leads Ocker to research and analyze the potential
sources of the story as well as the locations in the town that served as backdrop
for this classic American tale. These chapters that focused on the literature
and Ocker’s analysis of the influences and changes that Irving made for the
story were among my favorite in the book. He closely examines not only the
possible friends and acquaintances who may have influenced the characters in
the story, but also provides some possible interpretations of the meaning and themes
of the story as they relate to American literature of the time and present. Furthermore,
Ocker’s style is conversational and informal, more punning than pedantic, and
it makes the analysis more accessible and engaging. I found it fascinating to
learn more about the Revolutionary War’s influence on this story and the legend
of the Hessian soldier from the Battle of White Plains who was possibly decapitated
by a cannonball. Ocker talks to an author who traveled to Germany to learn more
about this possible connection, as well as other authors who have written about
Sleepy Hollow, the town and the story.
Beyond the story, Ocker also visits some haunted spots in
the area, sharing some possible sites to visit on a day trip. This kind of
travel writing is where Ocker shines, sharing some out of the way spots that
won’t necessarily show up in a guidebook. He provides some interesting stories behind
the lore of these locations and some ways to navigate to easier viewing (like
Raven Rock). I loved learning more about all of the legends, houses, rocks,
bridges, trees, and even restaurants, and it provides the beginnings of a fun
itinerary for visiting a town. In another chapter, Ocker also compares Sleepy
Hollow with America’s original terrifying town, Salem, Massachusetts, to note
how each obtained their reputation as a Halloween location and how this has
helped these town’s grow. In another chapter, Ocker visits several other
American cities and towns that are either named Sleepy Hollow or have some
connection to Washington Irving, whether it is visiting Ichibod’s Lounge in Las
Vegas or chatting with the resident historian of Sleepy Hollow Illinois. My
favorite chapter in the book, though, was Ocker’s detailed examination of all
of the movies, shows, and short films inspired by “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow.”
I had no idea that there were about 82 hours of shows and movies that were
based on the story, and Ocker provides a useful synopsis and evaluation of
these films and shows. Although he wasn’t able to find one of the more
interesting shows, Shirley Temple’s Storybook which features Boris Karloff,
he watched all of the other recreations and adaptations of this classic story
to see how the Headless Horseman has been represented in various time periods.
Although my first encounter with the Headless Horseman was through the 1949 Disney
short, I didn’t realize that it was also featured with The Wind and the
Willows, which is a British novel and somehow received a Disneyland ride. I
think a Sleepy Hollow ride would have been much better, but alas. This chapter
about the various interpretations of Irving’s story probably has the most
highlighting, and I have been creating a viewing list based on Ocker’s film
reviews. It was fascinating to see how the image of the Headless Horseman has
shifted over time, yet somehow still remains menacing even in children’s television
from the 1970s and 80s. Nevertheless, it’s also fascinating to see how in more
recent adaptations, the Headless Horseman exchanges his horse for a motorcycle
and is often depicted as a malevolent motorist with a detachable helmet.
There’s so much to like about this book, whether it’s the
history, the travel recommendations, the literary analysis, or the film
recommendations. J. W. Ocker takes readers on a wild ride through the forests
of West Chester County and the influences and legacy of America’s first
ghost/horror story “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow.” He brings us along with his
family, introducing us to historians, authors, and citizens of Sleepy Hollow and
its surrounding towns to learn more about the history and significance of the
town, its namesake story, and its author, Washington Irving, who, according to
Ocker, was the first American to make a living as a writer. Ocker’s passion and
love for the story and especially the Headless Horseman shines through all of
his interviews, questions, and explorations of the area, geographical,
historical, and literary. It’s a fascinating book that dives deep into an
important American legend, examining its modern day reverberations and
influence. Chasing the Headless Horseman is a wonderful read, especially
for those who love Halloween, fall, and American literature. Highly
recommended!
Note- I was lucky enough to visit the Alhambra in Granada,
Spain this past winter. I previously visited it 30 years before, and I wanted
to make sure I took my family there when we were in Spain, even though it meant
renting a car and driving for several hours from Seville. I also made sure that
I found where Washington Irving stayed during his time there, and where he was
inspired to write two books about this magnificent, historical palace. I remembered learning about Irving's visit and stay there when I first visited Spain as a high school student, but it was cool to see this again with my family. Ocker's book and this picture I took remind me of how important and unique Washington Irving was-- how we traveled around and shared his observations and reflections about these places for the broader American public who might not have been able to travel in the 19th century. It also demonstrates Irving's interest in culture and legends, and how he was like an early, informal anthropologist or folklorist, gathering and reproducing some of the history and legends of these places. He truly is an American original and I'm glad that Ocker's book celebrates his significance in American literature.
No comments:
Post a Comment